The wrong mental model
Most people debugging this start with the message: the subject line, the wording, the number of links. That is where spam advice has always pointed, and for transactional mail it is usually the least productive place to look.
Mailbox providers are making a judgement about the sender first. Content matters at the margin, once reputation has already put you near a threshold.
A new IP or domain has no reputation, which is not the same as good reputation
Sending fifty thousand messages on day one from a brand-new sending identity looks exactly like a spammer who just bought infrastructure, because it is what spammers do. Providers throttle or drop it.
Warm-up means increasing volume gradually so a pattern establishes. Two weeks is fast; six is common. There is no way to buy your way past it, and this is the constraint founders consistently underestimate when planning a launch.
The two numbers that decide it
Complaint rate and bounce rate. Complaints below 0.10% are healthy; 0.30% is where major providers stop accepting your mail. Hard bounces above around 5% signal you are sending to a list you do not maintain.
Both are lagging indicators of list hygiene, which is why they cannot be fixed the week you notice them.
Things that are genuinely content problems
- A single tracked link wrapping the whole message, on a shortener domain shared with other senders.
- An image-only email with almost no text — a long-standing spam signature.
- Mismatched display name and From address, which reads as impersonation.
- A reply-to on a domain unrelated to the sending domain.
- No plain-text alternative on an HTML message.
Debug in this order
Check authentication first, because it is binary and cheap to verify. Then reputation, because it explains most of the rest. Then content, which is where most people incorrectly start.
- Confirm SPF, DKIM and DMARC pass and align — read the raw headers of a message you actually received, not a testing tool's summary.
- Check your complaint and bounce rates against 0.10% and 5%.
- Check whether you are on a blocklist, and whether your IP is shared with someone who put you there.
- Check whether marketing and transactional mail share a domain.
- Only then look at the message itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Send transactional emails in under 3 minutes
EU-hosted delivery, custom SMTP relay, 100% SPF/DKIM alignment, and automated suppression firewalls. 6,000 free sends every month without a credit card.
Building SadaSend — transactional email with an MCP server that has a ceiling. Writes about deliverability, email infrastructure, and what happens when you hand an autonomous agent a sending credential.